If you're gonna run regular sized tires on it Id personally probably opt for the 3200Kv. If you're gonna run oversized tires then yes, Id go for the 2400Kv but I wouldnt run it on 4S.
I suspect 3S on a 4000Kv motor is going to run hot even on tall gearing in open area. Id personally go with something in the 2600-3200Kv range and use shorter gearing or just run that motor on 2S. Either way, Id keep an eye on motor and ESC temps. :2cents: